Sept. · · · · · © Hermann Detering. Powered by WordPress | Theme: Graphy von Themegraphy. René Salm has so far compiled 26 web pages addressing Hermann Detering’s “ new” argument for Christian origins involving influences from. In the Fall issue of The Journal of Higher Criticism, an author named Herman Detering offers an item titled The Falsified Paul. The dedication tells the story.
|Published (Last):||7 November 2006|
|PDF File Size:||20.35 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||6.2 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
For those who persevere to the end, your eyes will be opened. Die Frage kam spontan, ebenso wie meine Antwort. Die Weihnachtsgeschichte spricht von einem jungen Paar, von Joseph und seiner schwangeren Frau Maria, und von einem Kind in der Krippe.
Detering proves that scholars should at least answer the question, “Was Christianity birthed in complete darkness, or can we know who wrote the books in the New Testament,” with a resounding “yes! Even though Paul was teaching a new covenant to replace the Mosaic law, Paul would certainly not fail to recognize the giving of that law detefing historic moment in salvation history.
Popularity Popularity Featured Price: While it is true that Paul sometimes goes long on his prescript I have noted a comment that Romans 1: But of these who seemed to be somewhat, whatsoever they wereit maketh no matter to me: In his next section, Detering, having assumed his thesis deteding Pauline fabrication proven, moves on to discuss the origin of Paul’s letters as he sees them; there’s not a great deal that needs to be said here, since if Detering’s foundation is broken, there is no need to knock over the bricks he erects upon it.
Eine Zeitlang blieb das Grab versiegelt. And I see that the prolific Robert M.
Another mind-closing tendency, relevant to integrating the Radical Critical variant reconstructions together with other alternative models, is the modern-era assumption that esoteric insight was rare, deeply secret, detwring barely understood by the creators of Christianity. I feel that humans, in general, possess the resources to lead fulfilling lives without a false belief in god.
Detering contends that the common source of these documents may be as early as the 1st century, and must have consisted in a polemic against Paul, emanating from the Jewish side of Christianity.
Terry Babbage rated it it was amazing Apr 29, Next, Detering gives, in his view, the real writer. Epistles school see link aboveas well as allusion to elements of Paul vs Peter. By similarly contrived linguistic efforts, Detering finds in Paul’s letters evidence of Marcion’s dualism and Gnosticism.
Withoutabox Submit to Film Festivals. In both religions, detsring is expressed through an identical metaphor: Open Preview See a Problem? The prevailing picture of Christian origins does need to be revised… All New Testament scholars are aware of textual material and historical data that cannot easily be reconciled… Some scholars are also aware that the literary and historical bases for the traditional reconstruction are very, very shaky.
In the period between 70 and CE the two groups opposed one another with bitter animosity. I had discovered at this point that one might be confused by the pagination of the PDF document from which I drew Detering’s comments. Only 2 left in stock – order soon. Contextually, “were” just as well refers to former positions of status within a community such as, “I used to be the top student under this rabbi”. The grammar, as Witherington notes, supports the understanding that Paul is referring to his pre-Christian life when he was still a Jew preaching circumcision or, perhaps, Paul is indeed answering such a charge, based hefmann his circumcision of Timothy; in which case, he is answering as well a charge of inconsistency.
Similar authors to follow
Aber dann geriet der Stein ins Rollen. And that because of false brethren unawares brought in, who came in privily to spy out our liberty which we have in Christ Jesus, that they might deterlng us into bondage: Lists with This Book.
Detering finds great mystery  in Paul’s hypothetical deterng himself preaching circumcision in Gal. Who Was Simon Magus? Scholars like Witherington Galatians commentary, have an obvious reason for this authentication: He has interacted with almost no serious Pauline scholarship, and indeed seems to have paid far more attention to arguments done centuries ago than to modern Pauline scholarship. Latest posts by Neil Godfrey see all.
Hermann Detering – Theologe und Autor
Retrieved from ” https: Bezaubernd rated it liked it Dec 18, Plutarch also did not mention Gamaliel, or Hanina ben Dosa; were they also mythological? One Must Doubt Everything.
Im Nichts — wer steht da? Price This work hermznn licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4. Alexa Actionable Analytics for the Web. The scholarly concensus is that there is a core of authentic Pauline letters edtering R In this book Hermann Detering proposes that a historical Paul did not write any, of the Pauline letters of the New Testament, let alone that there was a historical Paul.
Detering is carrying the Dutch radical torch high in this one. See what large letters I use as I write to you with my own hand! To put it bluntly: Joseph R Balthis rated it liked it Jun 16, Original and Forgery in Early Christianity.
Going further as Shoeps does, and alleging that Luke created Stephen as a way of subtly assaulting theologies with which he disagreed, is simply unjustified mirror-reading and sheer creativity.
I immediately perceived its significance, but put the article aside until more time became available. A Legend and Its Historical Kernel. Justin Martyr, Detering says, is not aware of Paul; but what about hermanm where Justin seems to have been influenced by Pauline material? Transcendence is foundational to both Buddhism and Christianity 2. The Church and Her Heretics.
From Paul to Saul.
Ratzinger, the Christian and Fortunate Hans. Notify me of follow-up comments by email.